Published Articles


FROM THE ARENA
Column for the Anchorage Times 2 December 1990
by Wayne Anthony Ross

During the last six months to a year the local newspapers have been filled with stories about Alaskans battling with one another over the allocation of our fish and game resources. Native groups argue that they should have priority in the taking of fish and game, because of their heritage, culture, and traditions. Rural residents argue that they should have priority because of lifestyle, and need. Urban residents argue that they should be allowed participation because of the Constitution, fundamental fairness, and equality. Commercial users argue they should have use because of the need to make a living. And while we argue, and while we remain divided, "animal rights" groups, who don't want anybody to be able to use fish and game resources, laugh at us, and grow stronger.

The "animal rights movement" began to emerge in the mid 1970's with the publication of a book called Animal Liberation by Peter Singer. Mr. Singer's first chapter contained the basic premise of this movement in its title: "All Animals Are Equal". Denying the existence of the human soul, animal rights proponents hold that "Each sentient being should be valued in and for itself", and that "..there is no rational excuse left for killing animals, be they killed for food, science or sheer personal indulgence". Their philosophy would put an end to animal testing of medicines and surgical techniques, circuses, rodeos, bird cages, dog pens, the use of leather and furs, meat, milk, and eggs, and, of course, the practice of hunting and fishing. Make no mistake about it, these people are fanatics in their beliefs .Vowing: "no compromise on animal rights", animal rights individuals and groups have committed acts of terrorism and violence to achieve their goals.

In April 1987 the Animal Liberation Front torched a university building in California where research involving animals was being conducted. The same group tossed paint and acid on the homes and cars of employees of the San Diego Zoo. Bombs have been planted, people wearing fur coats have been attacked with paint and acid, and one woman was recently convicted for attempting to murder the president of a major corporation which teaches doctors surgical procedures using animals.

Recently, an organization called "Earth First" published information on how anti-cattle and anti- hunting people can go out, especially during hunting seasons, and shoot cattle with rifles or bows and arrows, and make it look like the work of hunters.

The inconsistencies of their philosophy doesn't bother animal rights advocates one bit. They apparently see no problem in killing cattle to try and turn cattlemen against hunters, but they do object to killing cattle for steaks or leather. For them "the end justifies the means", yet they oppose that belief in others. One wonders why, for example, they advocate killing cattle, yet oppose the use of mice in lab experiments, even when such research is necessary to save human lives! They declare that animals have the inherent right to survive but that apparently man does not, holding that man must sacrifice his interests in favor of the interests of animals.

We haven't seen too many animal rights advocates in Alaska, but even here their numbers are beginning to grow. Thankfully, Alaskan animal rights activists don't seem to be violent, but while many of us were finishing the remnants of our Thanksgiving turkey, (something Friends Of The Animals would hate us for), animal rights activists were marching up and down Anchorage streets last Saturday, protesting the trapping and sale of furs. One Anchorage resident, wearing a fur trimmed jacket smeared with paint, claimed, somewhat inconsistently that "It's completely Neanderthal to wear fur". The protesters were joined by an Assistant Attorney General, who wore a poster of a caged animal and the words "Don't be caught dead in a fur coat" taped to the back of her pink Gore-Tex parka.

Alaskan hunters and fishermen need to forget their differences, stop the petty bickering, and unite against our common foe, the animal rights advocates. So long as we are divided, so long as we try to get "our share" of the fish and game while attempting to deprive other Alaskans of theirs, we all stand to lose any rights to hunt and fish. Perhaps our new Governor, with wise leadership, can bring us all together, and help us recognize our real enemy. And a bit of house-cleaning, in the Department of Law, might not hurt either.

 

 


Attorneys | Support Staff | Legal Services | Forms | Contact Us | Published Articles | Links

Copyright 2008© Ross & Miner, Anchorage, Alaska All Rights Reserved                                       Site Design by Alaska Web Designs, LLC